During my downtime from actively running a game, I have started to work on my settings and I have discovered something upsetting. I have found better ideas for things, than those that I originally created or stole. Now, what do I do?
During the Dark Time, after the glory of Second Edition was over and before the messianic arrive of Third Edition, I decided to run a campaign that was set on a world other than Rilmorn. I had planned on using only modules and nothing else…No Gregory Created Stuff. I failed, but I did end up with a fairly cool setting based of B2 Keep on the Borderlands and Return to Keep on the Borderlands. The PCs started at and basecamped out of Kendal Keep, a keep on the borders of the Empire of Namoria. I never named the world, because I didn’t need it. Years and campaigns later, I would name it Terah. Now, I want to change its name to Nibiru. I never heard of Nibiru, until I was watching Scooby Doo! Mystery Incorporated. Later, when I was rewatching Star Trek: Into Darkness, I noticed the opening sequence took place on the world of Nibiru. Thus, my desire for the name change.
During the last game I ranin my Pellham campaign, I named an NPC Gabardine. I knew that she was one of five “sisters” and I decided that three of the others would be named Fescue, DoTerra, and Cusped. The fifth sister is to have an “E” name. I later decided that DoTerra would be an alchemist and Cusped, a mage working with the Teeth of Dahlver-Nar. Then, I decided I needed to have one sister that worked magic with plants and one that worked magic with cloth, but I’ve already got one name wrong…Gabardine is a florist.
What do I do? I retcon!
I can’t retcon, because I believe this (I wrote this as a rebuttal in a debate about Lucas’ retooling of Star Wars.”
To alter a work once it is released to the public is be unfair to the audience, forever tweaking something prevents it audience from being able to fully connect with the work, because there are multiple versions and analogues of the work and any of them could be the true work. I know how it feels to put something out there and then decide it is flawed. Even though I presented it to two different audiences, I should not have changed the wording of my poem. Now, there exist two quanta of the same work, but I have undermined the readers of the first version of the poem. I have effectively told my first readers that what they got was crap. It does not matter that there is very little to change in a two stanza poem, but it doesn’t matter. It says that I put out bad stuff that I of which wasn’t proud. Altering Star Wars is no different…
I can’t just change a draft and then run my campaign. I’ve already put these events out to the public. In days past, I told Mike Magee about the quintuplets born to a descendant of his character Gareth Eybender. I never got to run those NPCs at that time, so years later when I found Ptolus, I could lift the name Danar and rename Janel the Herald’s oldest child without incident. My two examples of Terah/Nibiru and Gabardine/Fescue are both events that have “been published.” They are given events.
I see way to fix each of these problems. With the Gabardine/Fescue event, I tell my plyers about my desired change and then if they agree with it, it changes. The Terah/Nibiru change is a more of a cheat. Not every culture calls the world upon which it dwells the same name. Even on Rilmorn, where everyone does use the same name, each culture alters the spelling and sometimes the pronunciation. So, Terah is the gnomes name for their former homeworld. Everyone else gets to call it Nibiru and I get to steal the crazy that goes along with the story of Planet X. Will I do them?
So, until we meet again, Game On!